Gunsmoke (1955)

S3E11 Fingered

The residents of Dodge begin to question Jim Cobbett (John Larch) after his second wife (Virginia Christine) mysteriously disappears, mirroring the fate of his first spouse (Karl Swenson makes an appearance). As whispers of doubt circulate, Jim finds himself in a precarious position, struggling to prove his innocence amid growing scrutiny and suspicion from those around him.