Hope & Faith (2003)

S3E22 Hope's Float

Hope shares memories with her family about the very first fight she and Charley ever had, back when they were dating in college during 1985. As she tells the story, flashbacks show that night was also when Charley first met Faith. The trouble started when Hope canceled their date to go to a Huey Lewis concert, choosing instead to comfort Faith, who was devastated after losing the lead in her high school play. Both Hope and Charley believed they missed the show, but as the tale unfolds, Hope uncovers shocking secrets Charley and Faith have hidden for years—plus one final twist about Hope herself.