Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2026)

S1E5 Simply Vanished

When Cheryl stumbles upon a concealed chute, it pulls her into a mystery that's been buried for decades—a cold case involving a vanished teenager. As she pieces together the clues, she uncovers a shocking connection to her own past. The discovery leads her to a birthday celebration unlike any other, where the truth finally surfaces, leaving her with a haunting gift she never expected.