Sabrina, the Teenage Witch (1996)

S3E1 It's A Mad Mad Mad Mad Season Opener

Sabrina finds herself stuck in the middle, unable to decide between Harvey and Dashiell, who eventually confront her with an ultimatum: she must pick one of them, or they will both walk away from her life. At the same time, her aunts deliver exciting news—she is finally set to obtain her witch's license.